Best Penny Sleeves 2022 – Top Picks

We’re here to take the headache out of shipping online. We’ve gone through all of the user reviews and have come up with our roundup to help make your choice easier. With so many options available to consumers, it’s more important than ever to have a list that you can trust!

The Best Penny Sleeves – Our Official Roundup

1
10 (Ten) Pack Lot of 100 Soft Sleeves / Penny Sleeve for Baseball Cards & Other Sports Cards (Packaging May Vary)
  • 10 (Ten) Packs of 100 Sleeve(s) per Pack
  • Size 2 5/8 X 3 5/8
  • Fits Top loaded Card Holder
  • Protect cards while handling
  • Great to Protect Single Cards - May Ship Ultra or BCW Brand Soft Sleeves
2
Ultra Pro Soft Card Sleeves 2-5/8" X 3-5/8", Ultra Clear (100Count)
  • 100-Count Archival-Grade No PVC and Acid-Free Soft Card Sleeves
  • Designed to hold standard 2-1/2" x 3-1/2" cards and cards up to 2-5/8" x 3-5/8"
  • Made from ultra clear polypropylene
  • Protects your collectibles from scratches
  • Ultra Pro Item Number 81126
Sale3
10,000 Ultra Pro Soft Transparent Card 'penny' sleeves for sports or game cards (1 Case = 100 packs100 sleeves)
  • The original "Penny Sleeves", Ultra PRO's clear Soft Trading Card Sleeves protect your valuable trading cards and gaming cards during sorting and gameplay
  • Designed to hold 2-1/2" x 3-1/2" (63.5mm x 88.9mm) standard size cards up to 35 points in thickness
  • Made with clear non-PVC, acid-free and archival-safe polypropylene film
  • Recommended for use with Ultra PRO's toploaders for the best inner and outer layer protection
  • 100 packs of 100 individual sleeves per pack
Sale4
WINTRA 400 Count Ultra Clear Penny Card Sleeves,2-5/8 x 3-5/8'' Soft Card Protectors for Baseball Cards and Other Sports Cards
  • 【SAFE & SECURE】: Archival-safe, acid free, no PVC, crystal clear, no sticking, easy to shuffle, save your valuable cards from scratches and peeling off. (Pictured cards are not included)
  • 【PERFECT FOR BASEBALL CARDS】: Size is 67 x 94mm(2 5/8 X 3 5/8inch), great to protect baseball cards and other sports cards. Offer additional protection in a simi-rigid card holder/topload hard card holder/binder.
  • 【GREAT AS SECOND PROTECTIVE LAYER】: Offer double protection for sleeved cards/rigid outer sleeves, make your precious trading cards in mint condition.
  • 【COST-EFFECTIVE】: These sleeves are lightweight but very protective. If you have hundreds of collectibles, it is the best cards protectors that won't break your bank.
  • 【NOTICE】: These penny card sleeves may too loose for standard size trading and playing cards. WINTRA have other soft protective holder for valuable cards with size of 64X89mm.
5
Set of 5 X 100 Soft Sleeves / Penny Sleeves for Pokemon, Magic, and Standard-Sized Sports and Trading Cards No PVC
  • 500 Soft sleeves / per order
  • Each sleeve size: 2-5/8” x 3-5/8” (66mm x 92mm)
  • Holds standard size cards
  • Clear polypropylene
  • Acid free – No PVC , Ultra clear
Sale6
BCW Standard Card Sleeves – 100 pk Case
  • 100 packs of 100 sleeves each
  • Acid free, polypropylene material
  • Fits inside topload card holders
  • Protect cards while handling
Sale7
Ultra Pro 5 (Five) Pack Lot of 100 Soft Sleeves/Penny Sleeve for Baseball Cards & Other Sports Cards
  • Five (5) Packs of 100 Sleeve(s) per Pack
  • Size 2 5/8 X 3 5/8
  • Fits Top loaded Card Holder
  • Protect cards while handling
  • Great to Protect Single Cards - May Ship Ultra or BCW Brand Soft Sleeves
8
TitanShield Economical Soft Penny Card Sleeves 2-5/8” x 3-5/8” (67x94mm), Ultra Clear (500 Count)
  • Actual Sleeve Size: 67x94mm
  • For standard sized cards up to 35pt.
  • 125 sleeves per pack - 25% more than a standard 100-pack penny sleeves.
  • 60 microns thick - 20% thicker than a standard 50 micron penny sleeve.
  • Acid-free, no pvc, made with ultra high clarity archival safe polypropylene material.
Sale9
10 Packs Beckett Shield Clear Soft Card Sleeves
  • For standard sized cards up to 35pt.
  • 10 Packs. Comes in packs of 1000 Sleeves Total
  • Sleeve dimensions are 2-5/8″ X 3-5/8″ (66.7mm X 92.1mm)
  • PP material. PVC Free
  • No collection without protection – Defend your collection with Beckett Shield and keep your cards in mint condition.
10
TitanShield Economical Soft Penny Card Sleeves 2-5/8” x 3-5/8” (67x94mm), Ultra Clear (1000 Count)
  • Actual Sleeve Size: 67x94mm
  • For standard sized cards up to 35pt.
  • 125 sleeves per pack - 25% more than a standard 100-pack penny sleeves.
  • 60 microns thick - 20% thicker than a standard 50 micron penny sleeve.
  • Acid-free, no pvc, made with ultra high clarity archival safe polypropylene material.

What To Know Before Shopping For The Best Penny Sleeves

Our Preferred Shopping Partner – You’ll notice that as you click on the products on our lists that youll be taken to the largest online retailer in the world. We chose Amazon as our product partner because of it’s brand recognition, and great customer service. You wont have to worry about getting an inauthentic Penny Sleeves when you purchase through our website. 

Pricing – We always consider pricing, and work to provide you the best seling items, at the best prices, however we do not control the prices of items on our shopping partners. We work to make it easy for you to click through and find the latest, most up to date prices. 

Consider Your Specific Application – Make sure that you are shopping for your specific needs. What is best for one person may not always be best for you. Don’t let a lower price on an item put you off, if that item has the features and design that are best suited for you. 

Ratings and Reviews – Sorting through hundreds of reviews is both time consuming, and taxing! We’ve already done that, and taken the tough work out of shopping so that you are left with a list of the best selling, best reviewed Penny Sleeves to choose from. You can also easily click through and see al of the reviews on our shopping partner’s website 

How To Chose The Right Penny Sleeves For You

There’s a ton of choices for just about anything you shop for, so what should you actually be considering? In addition to the aforementioned attention to your specific needs, there’s really only a few considerations – price, quality/dependibility, and the reviews of your peers. If you can find items that meet your needs, are priced in your range, and have reviews that showcase the quality, then you should feel confident in making your purchase!

Is Buying a Penny Sleeves Really Worth It?

The one thing we can’t do, is choose for you. We feel that if an item made one of our lists, it has merit as something that is “worth it”, as long as it meets your needs, and fits inside your pricerange. We’re here to give you the best possible choices, and while we feel it’s definitely worth it, we want you to as well. 

Is The Most Expensive Penny Sleeves Always The best?

We covered a bit of this earlier, and the answer is no, because often, there is no “best”, but only a “best” for you! You need to decide which product has the best chance of making your life easier and meeting your needs, regardless of price. 

Wrapping Up

Our goal is simply to help you make better shopping choices, and we hope that our list and advice do just that. We are here to empower you, the consumer, with the right knowledge, and the right items to get the job done. We’re here to be the expert in your corner and hope to be able to provide you with an excellent shopping experience. If there is anything we can do to make your life easier, please let us know!